GP: Sabean, Giants walking a thin line

Scottyo:

I have read many articles this year of the 2008-09 season on the ups and downs of our San-Francisco Giants, and this article by Andrew Matheson makes the most sense to me than any.

I have to say I totally agree that there really isn't a bat worth "selling the farm for." I think, as of years past, big contract signings in the middle of the season from last year are now hurting the Giants now. Zito, Renteria, and even Randy Johnson are huge contracts that, if their productivity was for-seen, probably would not have happened.

Nonetheless, it is what it is, and this surprising 2009 season for us Giants fans brings a glimmer of promise of what this team can be in just a couple of years.

But can general manager Brian Sabean hold on to that promise without giving away arguably one of the best if not the best farm system in the league to save his own job? I think he now is making wise decisions in this market and banking that his pitching staff can, at least, get him to the playoffs, which is more i think then anyone could really have expected.

I do think, however, that another key bat is needed and I wouldn't think it would have to be a huge blue chip player now as they have added Garko to the lineup.

Green Phone:

Dear Scottyo,

Brian Sabean treaded a thin line nicely this week when the Giants signed Garko and Freddy Sanchez. The franchise added some much-needed offensive power without having to sacrifice its future.

Anytime you can aquire an All-Star second baseman and a proven first baseman who can hit the ball and score runs at the cost of minor league talent, you do it. Keep in mind, Garko and Sanchez could be playing in San Francisco for a while; they are both in their prime.

In making said moves, the Giants have upped their chances of making the postseason while ditching the horse that got them where they were at the start of this week: a game out of leading the National League wild card race.

If there's one thing the San Francisco Giants have, it's pitching. They have enough young prospects to keep their rotation at high level through the next decade.

Trading to make a good team better is a delicate process, and Sabean has done exceptionally.

What's your take?

Did the Giants make the right moves at the trade deadline? Is Ryan Garko and Freddy Sanchez enough to reach the playoffs? Was Tim Alderson too much to give up for Freddy Sanchez? Did the Giants need to trade for another pitcher?

Let the Green Phone know by calling (408) 842-9069.

---

Free Lance Sports Staff Got a question or a comment? Send us an email.